|
|
| Reprinted
with permission from Washingtonpost.Newsweek Interactive and The
Washington Post.
Laughter's Link to Health May Be in the Blood; [FINAL Edition] |
|
Rob Stein . The Washington Post. Washington, D.C.: Mar 14, 2005. pg. A.10 |
![]()
|
Copyright The Washington Post Company Mar 14, 2005 According to the Bible, "a merry heart doeth good like a medicine." Now,
modern science may be validating that Old Testament proverb -- a good
laugh may actually help fend off heart attacks and strokes. "We believe laughing is good for your health," said Michael Miller of
the University of Maryland School of Medicine in Baltimore, who led the
research. "And we think we have evidence to show why that's the case." A growing body of other evidence has suggested that negative emotions,
particularly depression and stress, can be harmful, making people more
prone to illness, more likely to experience suffering from their ailments
and less likely to recover as quickly, or at all. One recent study even
found sudden emotional shock can trigger life-threatening heart symptoms
that many doctors mistake for a classic heart attack. Miller himself,
along with his colleagues, had done a study that found people who have
a negative reaction to social situations tend to be more prone to heart
disease. But far less has been done to examine whether positive emotions can reduce
the risk and complications of illness. "The focus is always on the negative aspects," he said. "We thought,
'Why not look at the opposite?' " So they decided to examine the ability of blood vessels to expand --
known as vasodilation. Poor vasodilation can increase the risk of heart
attacks and strokes by making the passageways prone to being blocked,
cutting off vital blood flow. The researchers asked 20 healthy men and women to watch clips of two
movies -- either the violent opening battle scene in the 1998 film "Saving
Private Ryan" or a humorous scene from a comedy, such as the 1996 "Kingpin." The researchers tested the subjects' vasodilation, before and after the
movie, by constricting and releasing an artery in their arms with a blood
pressure cuff and then using ultrasound to measure how the blood vessels
were functioning. The researchers discovered striking differences depending on which movie
the volunteers had watched. Blood flow was significantly reduced in 14
of the 20 volunteers who saw the stressful film. In contrast, blood flow
markedly increased in 19 of the 20 volunteers after watching the funny
movie, the researchers reported last week at a meeting of the American
College of Cardiology in Orlando. Overall, blood flow decreased by about 35 percent after experiencing
stress but increased 22 percent after laughter -- an improvement equivalent
to that produced by a 15- to 30-minute workout. "It was a pretty dramatic difference," Miller said. Previous research has indicated that stress hormones may be the primary
culprit by which negative emotions harm health. When a person is under
stress, the body pumps out hormones such as adrenalin and cortisol. That
is designed to prime the body for a fight or a flight, but the hormones
can have detrimental effects on the body, including suppressing the immune
system and constricting blood vessels. Miller and his colleagues hypothesize that laughter may have a contrasting
effect, causing the body to release other natural chemicals known as endorphins
-- pleasure-producing agents best known for producing the "runner's high"
-- that may counteract the effects of stress hormones and cause blood
vessels to dilate. The researchers acknowledge they are still a long way from proving their
hypothesis or fully understanding the process, but they say the theory
makes sense. "Conceivably, when you laugh you send a signal to the brain to release
these endorphins, and these may activate receptors to release other chemicals,
perhaps including nitric oxide, which is known to enhance blood vessel
dilation," Miller said. Laughter may also use similar mechanisms to help boost the immune system
and reduce the amount of inflammation in the body, which has been linked
to an increased risk of a host of health problems, said Lee Berk, an associate
professor of health promotion and education who studies laughter at Loma
Linda University in California. "Laughter is not dissimilar from exercise," Berk said. "It's not going
to cure someone from stage three cancer, but in terms of prevention it
does make sense. In a sense, we have our own apothecary on our shoulders.
Positive emotions such as laughter affect your biology." Other researchers said the findings add new insight into the interplay
of emotions and health. "This is just the latest example of the importance of the mind- body
relationship," said Herbert Benson, who studies emotions and health at
Harvard Medical School. "This shows that we have to look not only towards
how to reduce stress but how we can elicit positive feelings, as well." Heart specialists agreed. "We've known that there's an association between state of mind and cardiovascular
health," said Stuart Seides, associate director of cardiology at Washington
Hospital Center. "This type of study gives us a peek into the mechanism." Robert Provine, a University of Maryland psychologist who also studies
laughter, was somewhat more cautious. It remains unclear whether the act
of laughter was really at work in the movie- watching volunteers, since
the researchers did not actually measure how much they laughed, he said. "The results could be the result of just the act of watching the movie.
Or maybe it's just the act of engaging in something interesting that doesn't
cause stress," Provine said. Miller acknowledged he has no way to know for sure that laughing per
se produced the effect he measured. "Is it laughing or just feeling good? We don't know at this time. But
clearly laughter is an active process, and probably a good belly laugh
will be better than just smiling. I think this active process helps release
endorphins," he said. Provine, despite his doubts about the study, is all for laughter. "I strongly recommend laughter, based on the fact that a life of laughter
is better than one without it," Provine said. "It feels better when you
do it." Miller envisions a time when doctors might recommend that everyone get
15 to 20 minutes of laughter a day in the same way they recommend at least
30 minutes of daily exercise. "Wouldn't it be ironic if it turns out that laughing 15 to 20 minutes
a day would be added as part of overall good health habits, like running?"
Miller asked. He added that he would not recommend that people replace their daily
trips to the gym with a Marx Brothers movie, but they could consider adding
activities that make them laugh. "There's no downside that I know of to laughing," Miller said. "Based
on these results, I am happy to recommend laughing to my patients."
Copyright 2005, Washingtonpost.Newsweek
Interactive and The
Washington Post. All Rights Reserved. |